The Mauve Media Conversations
The relationship between public relations and the media has always been shaped by one essential question: what makes a story worth telling?
In an increasingly crowded media landscape, where visibility can be negotiated, narratives are carefully crafted and the lines between editorial and commercial often intersect, the value of a story lies in more than its ability to secure a headline. It lies in its relevance, credibility and the conversation it leaves behind.
Through The PR Playbook, The Mauve explores the evolving dynamics of public relations, journalism and the business of media, bringing industry voices into conversations that go beyond conventional communication strategies.
In this exclusive edition of The Mauve Media Conversations, we speak with Dhruv Goel, Founder & Managing Partner, Brand Catapult, on what makes a story newsworthy, how PR agencies assess media partnerships, the growing influence of paid placements and why editorial credibility remains one of the industry’s most valuable currencies.
EXCLUSIVE
The Mauve Media Conversations
By Dhruv Goel, Founder & Managing Partner, Brand Catapult
The PR Playbook
1. What makes a story genuinely newsworthy, and what determines whether it gets pitched?
Over the past 11 years, working across brands and the communications industry, I’ve come to see newsworthiness as the intersection of a brand’s development and a larger shift in its market. A business milestone may matter to the company, but its editorial significance depends on what it reveals about the industry or its consumers.
In hospitality, for instance, a restaurant opening can be an opportunity to examine the growing appetite for a particular cuisine, changing dining habits or new expectations around the guest experience. The announcement is the starting point; the larger development gives it context. Our role is to identify that connection and build a story around it. The strongest pitches explain not just what a brand is doing, but why it matters now.
2. How do you decide which publications make it to your media list?
We begin by asking what the story needs to achieve and who would find it relevant. A founder’s business journey may be suited to a business publication, while a new culinary concept may be more appropriate for a food or lifestyle platform. The same brand can have several legitimate stories, but they will not all belong in the same publication.
We also examine a publication’s editorial track record, the subjects it returns to and the audience it has built around them. This requires ongoing judgement rather than relying on a static contact database. A media list is most effective when it reflects a considered understanding of where each story belongs, rather than how many outlets an agency can reach.
3. What makes a publication valuable to a PR agency beyond its readership numbers?
A publication brings value through the authority it has established with its readers and the context in which it presents a brand. Reach tells us how many people may encounter a story; it does not, on its own, tell us whether they will consider it credible, remember it or act on it.
For a hospitality brand, a detailed feature in a respected food publication can help shape how a restaurant or cuisine is understood. A business profile, meanwhile, can place the same company within a larger conversation about entrepreneurship or expansion. These outcomes are different, and both can be valuable. The important consideration is what the publication contributes beyond exposure.
The Business of Media
4. How frequently do you encounter media houses requesting payment to publish a client’s story?
Paid proposals are a regular feature of media conversations today, although their frequency varies across publications and formats. What matters is understanding whether the proposal is for a defined commercial package or whether payment is being associated with coverage that appears to be independently selected by the editorial team.
From an agency’s perspective, that distinction has direct implications for how we advise clients. A paid opportunity should be assessed on its deliverables and commercial value, while an earned editorial opportunity depends on the merit of the story. Both can be part of a communications programme, but they should be evaluated on different terms. Clarity at the outset helps clients make informed decisions about both their investment and their reputation.
5. Has media coverage become increasingly pay-to-play, particularly in lifestyle, fashion and luxury?
The commercial pressures on publishing have become more visible as media businesses diversify their revenue through branded content, events, digital partnerships and social platforms. Lifestyle and luxury are particularly active categories for these arrangements because brands often seek association with a publication’s audience, aesthetic and cultural influence.
The concern arises when commercial visibility begins to carry the same perceived weight as independent editorial judgement. If every prominent placement is treated as proof of a brand’s relevance, the distinction between buying exposure and earning recognition becomes blurred. That can create unrealistic expectations for clients and weaken the value of editorial coverage over time. Paid media can buy a defined opportunity to be seen; it cannot, by itself, establish why a brand deserves attention.
6. How do you distinguish between earned editorial coverage, sponsored content and advertorials?
The distinction lies in who determines the story, who funds the placement and how the content is presented to the reader. Earned editorial coverage is selected independently by the publication. Sponsored content and advertorials involve a commercial arrangement, with agreed deliverables and appropriate disclosure.
Each format can serve a legitimate purpose. Paid content can be useful when a brand needs control over messaging, timing or placement. Earned coverage offers the independent consideration of a journalist or editor. The mistake is not choosing one over the other; it is evaluating them as though they deliver the same outcome. A sound communications strategy should be clear about what is being purchased, what is being earned and how success will be measured.
7. When a publication requests payment, how do you evaluate whether the investment is worthwhile for your client?
I look at the opportunity as a business decision, not a prestige decision. The publication’s name may be recognisable, but that alone does not justify the cost. We assess who the content will reach, what prominence it will receive, which deliverables are guaranteed and whether the investment offers better value than other available channels.
We also consider the objective behind the spend. If a client needs a defined placement to support a campaign, a paid package may be appropriate. If the intention is to establish the founder as an independent industry voice, a commercial feature may not achieve the same purpose. The recommendation has to follow the intended outcome, not the appeal of seeing a brand in a particular publication.
8. In your experience, how much does today’s media coverage depend on the strength of a story versus the budget behind it?
The balance depends on the kind of visibility being pursued. In paid media, budget determines the commercial opportunity available, subject to the agreed package. In earned media, the story must stand on its own merits, and publication is never guaranteed. The two models therefore answer different needs.
The challenge for brands is to avoid treating every appearance as an equivalent achievement. A paid placement can deliver a planned message to a defined audience, while independent editorial coverage can demonstrate that a story has been selected on its merits. Neither should be judged by placement count alone. The more useful measure is whether the outcome advances the brand’s intended position and whether the investment or editorial attention was justified.
The Changing Media Landscape
9. What separates publications that consistently receive pitches from those approached only occasionally?
It comes down to how clearly an agency understands a publication’s editorial priorities. When a publication develops a recognisable approach to its subject, it becomes easier to identify stories that genuinely fit. That understanding also raises the quality of the pitch: instead of sending a general announcement, we can bring forward a specific angle that suits the publication’s readership.
The reverse is equally important. Sending the same announcement to every outlet may increase the volume of outreach, but it rarely improves the quality of the conversation. Publications are more likely to receive considered proposals when agencies have taken the time to understand what they cover and how they approach it. Relevance is demonstrated through the pitch itself, not claimed in the introduction.
10. How do you evaluate emerging digital publications with smaller but highly relevant audiences?
I look at whether a publication has built a community around a clear subject and whether its content gives that audience a reason to return. A smaller platform can offer considerable value if it has developed a credible voice within a specific category. For a hospitality brand, a publication with an engaged readership interested in food, travel or dining culture may be particularly relevant to the right story.
However, a niche audience is not automatically an influential one. We consider the quality of the content, consistency of coverage, audience engagement and the publication’s standing within its field. Emerging platforms should have the opportunity to demonstrate their value, but that value needs to be assessed on evidence rather than novelty alone.
11. What can publications do to become more credible and valuable media partners for PR agencies?
Publications can strengthen their position by developing a clear editorial identity, communicating their areas of interest and maintaining transparency around commercial offerings. Consistent editorial direction helps agencies bring better-informed pitches, while clear commercial terms allow brands to understand exactly what an investment includes.
There is also an opportunity for publications to communicate the themes they intend to explore, giving agencies the chance to identify relevant founders, specialists and industry perspectives in advance. This can lead to stronger stories than reactive outreach around individual announcements. The relationship works best when agencies understand what a publication wants to investigate and journalists retain full discretion over what merits publication.
12. What would encourage your agency to pitch a publication like The Mauve more frequently?
For The Mauve, I see an opportunity to develop a distinctive perspective on how lifestyle and luxury are changing as businesses respond to new consumer expectations. Beyond launches and profiles, there are substantive conversations around how luxury is being redefined, how hospitality brands are building long-term relevance and how consumer aspirations are influencing the way businesses position themselves.
A clear editorial direction around these themes would help us identify founders and industry leaders who can contribute informed perspectives. Our aim would be to bring forward stories that examine a wider development through the experience of a brand or its leadership, rather than simply present a company announcement. That approach can create a more sustained and useful exchange between the publication and the industry.
One Final Thought
If you could change one thing about the relationship between PR agencies and media houses today, what would it be?
I would like the industry to place greater value on the quality of the story than on the volume of coverage generated. Agencies are often expected to demonstrate visibility through numbers, while publications operate under commercial pressures of their own. In that environment, it becomes easy to prioritise the number of appearances over what those appearances actually contribute.
For PR to retain its value, agencies must exercise judgement about what deserves to be pitched, and publications must preserve the distinction between editorial selection and commercial partnership. The objective should not be to secure coverage at every opportunity, but to build a body of communication that strengthens a brand’s standing over time. A hundred appearances are not necessarily more valuable than one story that changes how an audience understands a brand.











